The Neuroscience of Proposal Success: Understanding SME Resistance and How to Change It

Ideas at Dawn
Jun 25
2 min read

Imagine this: you have a high-stakes proposal due in two weeks, and you know the perfect subject matter expert (SME) to help make it shine. You send a detailed email with a comprehensive questionnaire, schedule a meeting, and then… nothing but one-word answers and “I’m too busy.”

If you’ve managed proposals in the AEC industry, this frustration is all too common. But the reality is that your SME isn’t being difficult—they're responding to cognitive overload.

The Coaching Call That Changed Everything

Recently, during a coaching call, I stumbled upon insights about how our brains work under pressure. I learned that our brains instinctively protect us from cognitive overload, and traditional proposal processes trigger these protective mechanisms.

Understanding Cognitive Load in Proposals

Here’s what neuroscience tells us about cognition under stress:

Decision Fatigue: Daily decisions drain mental energy, making even simple choices feel overwhelming by late afternoon.
Multitasking is a Myth: Switching between tasks lowers efficiency and increases stress.
Creativity Needs Safety: Fear or pressure shuts down the brain's innovation centers.
Blank Page Syndrome: Starting from scratch requires more mental effort than revising existing content.

Traditional proposal methods often disrupt these principles by presenting SMEs with extensive questionnaires and high expectations without proper context.

The Real Cost of Cognitive Overload

When SMEs face cognitive overload, several negative outcomes occur:

Quality Suffers: Overwhelm leads to generic content rather than thoughtful responses.
Engagement Drops: SMEs avoid proposal-related communication, causing delays.
Stress Increases: This creates tension and complicates future collaborations.
Opportunities Are Lost: Rushed, generic content diminishes chances of success.

The Brain-Friendly Proposal Revolution

Here are strategies to align your approach with human psychology:

Strategic Information Chunking: Break requests into manageable parts. Instead of asking for everything at once, start with a single, focused question.
AI-Assisted Content Creation: Use AI tools to create initial drafts, allowing SMEs to refine and enhance rather than start from scratch. This method alleviates the pressure of a blank page.
Create a Safe Environment: Ensure SMEs feel comfortable sharing their insights without fear of judgment or tight deadlines.

By understanding and addressing the cognitive challenges faced by SMEs, you can foster better collaboration and improve the quality of your proposals, ultimately leading your firm to greater success.

Tap into progressive AEC insights—join our community today and subscribe to our weekly email here.